Stuffing or dressing: The debate rages on with a few twists thrown in

Whether the dish is called stuffing or dressing depends on who’s cooking, and what goes into it depends on the region and the family. Oysters, cornbread, black rice and chestnuts all turn up in Thanksgiving recipes, and each carries a story. One is a farmed version of wild rice that Minnesota researchers began developing in the 1950s; another was an everyday food in Appalachia until a blight struck, and it now appears mostly at the holidays. kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm$@FE96C? 4@@A2C:D@?[ 2C6 3FDJ AFEE:?8 DEF77:?8 :?E@ E96 3:C5] ~?6 $@FE9 r2C@=:?2 8F:56 7C2>6D E96 C:G2=CJ 2D 4@C?3C625 5C6DD:?8 G6CDFD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F?8CJ4@@^3C625\DEF77:?8^Qm3C625 DEF77:?8k^2m[ 2?5 :E D2JD E96 $@FE9 92D 2=C625J A:4<65 2 D:56]k^Am k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qmu@@5 D276EJ :D @?6 C62D@? E96 5:D9 :D 32<65 @? :ED @H?k^9am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmu656C2= k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]7D:D]FD52]8@G^?6HD\6G6?ED^?6HD\AC6DD\C6=62D6D^9@H\4@@<\EFC<6J\DEF77:?8\D276=JQ C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm7@@5\D276EJ 8F:52?46k^2m 5@6D ?@E C64@>>6?5 DEF77:?8 2 H9@=6 EFC<6J[ 4:E:?8 2 9:896C C:D< @7 4C@DD\4@?E2>:?2E:@? 2?5 2 =@?86C 4@@< E:>6[ 2?5 C64@>>6?5D 4@@<:?8 E96 DEF77:?8 D6A2C2E6=J] ~?6 C68:@?2= 8F:56 D2JD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^6IA=@C6362F7@CED4]4@>^5C6DD:?8\@C\DEF77:?8\:ED\?@\4@?E6DE\:?\E96\D@FE9^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm32<:?8 5C6DD:?8 :? 2 5:D9k^2m 2G@:5D H@CC:6D 23@FE F?56C4@@<65 DEF77:?8] r@C?3C625 5C6DD:?8 @7E6? 32<6D :? 23@FE 92=7 2? 9@FC[ 56A6?5:?8 @? E96 2>@F?E]k^Am k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qm~JDE6CD 567:?6 E96 4@2DE2= G6CD:@?Dk^9am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E96=@42=A2=2E6]4@>^2CE:4=6D^62EJ>@=@8J\@JDE6C\5C6DD:?8Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm~JDE6C 5C6DD:?8k^2m :D 62E6? 7C@> }6H t?8=2?5 5@H? E96 t2DE r@2DE E@ E96 {@H4@F?ECJ 2?5 2C@F?5 E96 vF=7[ H96C6G6C @JDE6CD 2C6 A=6?E:7F=] ~JDE6CD 2C6 A2:C65 H:E9 D2FD286 2?5 >FD9C@@>D[ 2?5 E96 3C625 F?56C?62E9 42? 36 H9:E6[ H962E @C 4@C?3C625]k^Am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm%96 5:D9 364@>6D 5:DE:?4E=J $@FE96C? @?46 :E :?4=F56D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7@@55C:?<=:76]4@>^G2C:2E:@?D\@7\4@C?3C625^Qm4@C?3C625k^2m] t2E:?8 @JDE6CD @?=J :? >@?E9D H:E9 2? # H2D =@?8 4@?D:56C65 D276C[ D:?46 E96 324E6C:F> k6>m':3C:@k^6>m E9C:G6D :? H2C> H2E6C[ >2:?=J 7C@> |2J E9C@F89 ~4E@36C] r@=5\492:? >2?286>6?E 2?5 E288:?8 ?@H EC24< 9@H @JDE6CD C6249 >2C<6E[ 3FE E96 324E6C:F> k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=DF2846?E6C]4@>^2CE:4=6D^A286`fdfbcdbhged_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm42? 36 AC6D6?E J62C\C@F?5k^2m[ 2?5 E9@C@F89 4@@<:?8 C6>@G6D E96 C:D<]k^Am k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qmr@C?3C625 5C6DD:?8 92D 2 =@?8 $@FE96C? 9:DE@CJk^9am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmr@C?3C625 5C6DD:?8 36=@?8D E@ $@FE96C? 7@@5 4F=EFC6 2D >F49 2D 8C:ED @C 3:D4F:ED 5@[ 2?5 :ED 9:DE@CJ CF?D 324< E@ “k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^6IA=@C6362F7@CED4]4@>^5C6DD:?8\@C\DEF77:?8\:ED\?@\4@?E6DE\:?\E96\D@FE9^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm256 :? E96 $@FE9 3J 7CJ:?8 52J\@=5 4@C?3C625 H:E9 @?:@?D 2?5 D62D@?:?8D :? 2 D<:==6E] xED 8C2:?J E6IEFC6 2?5 D=:89E 3FEE6C>:=< E2?8 A2:C H6== H:E9 @E96C $@FE96C? 5:D96D]k^Am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^6IA=@C6362F7@CED4]4@>^5C6DD:?8\@C\DEF77:?8\:ED\?@\4@?E6DE\:?\E96\D@FE9^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm~?6 $@FE9 r2C@=:?2 C64:A6k^2m DE2CED H:E9 4CF>3=65 52J\@=5 4@C?3C625 4@>3:?65 H:E9 46=6CJ 2?5 @?:@? D2FEé65 :? 3FEE6C] w6C3D DF49 2D D286 2?5 E9J>6 8@ :? 2=@?8 H:E9 2 362E6? 688 2?5 6?@F89 A@F=ECJ DE@4< E@ >2<6 2 D@FAJ >:IEFC6 4=@D6 E@ A2?42<6 32EE6C]k^Am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmx? $@FE9 r2C@=:?2[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E2DE6D56=:4:@FD]4@>^QmC64:A6Dk^2m 72G@C @JDE6CD :? r92C=6DE@? 2?5 E96 {@H4@F?ECJ[ H9:=6 4@@2J 8@ :?E@ E96 5C6DD:?8 @C :?E@ E96 8C2GJ D6CG65 @G6C :E]k^Am k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qm%96 3=24< C:46 :? >2?J DEF77:?8 C64:A6D :D ?@E H:=5k^9am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmq=24< C:46 :D 4@>>@? :? %92?^ECF6\DE@CJ\H:=5\C:46\?@CE9\2>6C:42D\>@DE\>:DF?56CDE@@5\8C2:?^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmA255J C:46k^2m[ 2 72C>65 4C@A E92E |:??6D@E2 C6D62C496CD 3682? 56G6=@A:?8 7C@> H:=5 C:46 :? E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4F=EFC2=DFCG:G2=]@C8^?@56^bfddQ C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm`hd_Dk^2m] qJ E96 `he_D[ :E H2D A=2?E65 :? C@HD :? 7=@@565 A255:6D 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D2G6FC]4@>^ECF6\DE@CJ\H:=5\C:46\?@CE9\2>6C:42D\>@DE\>:DF?56CDE@@5\8C2:?^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm92CG6DE65 3J 4@>3:?6k^2m]k^Am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm(:=5 C:46 =@@ E96 A255J <:?5 D@=5 :? 8C@46CJ DE@C6D[ 2?5 :E :D 92C56C E@ 7:?5] ~?46 4@@<65[ :E EFC?D 2 >:= =2<6 E@ =2<6 2?5 92D 2 D>@A7:C6\=:<6 7=2G@C[ H9:=6 A255J C:46 :D ;6E 3=24<]k^Am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmx? ?@CE96C? |:??6D@E2[ E96 H:=5 C:46 92CG6DE =2DED 23@FE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D2G6FC]4@>^ECF6\DE@CJ\H:=5\C:46\?@CE9\2>6C:42D\>@DE\>:DF?56CDE@@5\8C2:?^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmEH@ H6636Ck^2m] w2CG6DE6CD A@=6 42?@6D E9C@F89 56?D6 C:46 DE2?5D 2?5 FD6 H@@56? DE:4@<6\5CJ:?8 C:46 :? 3:C49\32C< G6DD6=D 367@C6 <6EE=6D 42>6 :?E@ FD6 27E6C 4@=@?:2= 4@?E24E] %@52J[ D@>6 A2C496CD FD6 :C@? <6EE=6D[ H9:=6 @E96CD FD6 =2C86 DE66=\5CF> 32CC6=D @G6C H@@5 7:C6D] #:46 42>AD A2DD E96 6C:42? 496DE?FEk^2m @?46 8C6H 24C@DD E96 62DE6C? &?:E65 $E2E6D[ 7C@> D@FE96C? |2:?6 E@ v6@C8:2 2?5 H6DE E@ ~9:@[ 2?5 :E DE@@5 6DA64:2==J E9:4< :? D@FE96C? pAA2=249:2] |2?J EC66D 8C6H @? 4@>>@? =2?5 @A6? E@ 2?J@?6 H9@ H2?E65 E@ 7@C286[ H9:49 >256 E96 ?FED 6DA64:2==J G2=F23=6 E@ 6?D=2G65 2?5 A@@C 72>:=:6D] u2>:=:6D 2E6 E96 ?FED[ C2465 9@8D 2?5 EFC<6JD E@ E96 EC66D[ 2?5 EC2565 ?FED 2E 86?6C2= DE@C6D 7@C 8@@5D DF49 2D 4@7766 2?5 DF82C] %96 DEC@?8[ 62DJ\E@\H@C< H@@5 925 :ED @H? FD6D[ 2?5 :ED E2??:?D H6?E :?E@ E2??:?8[ H9:=6 7@=< >65:4:?6D H6C6 >256 7C@> E96 =62G6D]k^Am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmx? z6?EF43@2ED >256 :E A@DD:3=6 E@ D9:A 496DE?FED 36J@?5 E96 =@42= 2C62 :? E96 62C=J `ge_D[ 2?5 C@25D 2?5 C2:=C@25D 6IA2?565 E96 EC256 :? E96 7@==@H:?8 564256D] #64@C5D DF886DE ':C8:?:2’D 496DE?FE 4C@A E@E2=65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^52:=J];DE@C]@C8^H96?\496DE?FED\H6C6\2?\6G6CJ52J\7@@5^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQma >:==:@? A@F?5Dk^2m 3J `h`c] p >2DD:G6 3=:89E H2D 2=C625J DAC625:?8 E96?[ 2?5 3J `hc_ ?62C=J gdT @7 E96 496DE?FE EC66D :? E96 vC62E $>@@C6 E:65 E@ E96 H:?E6C 9@=:52JD E92? 496DE?FED[ H96E96C E96J 2C6 C@2DE65 @C 7@=565 :?E@ DEF77:?8[ 2?5 E96J 2C6 AC@323=J 8@?6 7C@> <:E496?D 27E6C }6H *62C’D] %96 D62D@? 3682? :? =2E6 72==[ H96? 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^52:=J];DE@C]@C8^H96?\496DE?FED\H6C6\2?\6G6CJ52J\7@@5^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm496DE?FE DE@C>k^2m @7 8FDEJ H:?5D =67E E96 8C@F?5 DEC6H? H:E9 ?FED 2?5 @776C65 >2?J 72>:=:6D C6=:67 7C@> 9F?86C] ~?46 E96 3=:89E DAC625[ E96 496DE?FE C646565 :?E@ ?@DE2=8:4 ?@G6=EJ :? E96 p>6C:42? 5:6E]k^Am k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qm%96 D:56 5:D9 :D E96 DE2C @7 E96 >62=k^9am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmr9@AA65 92C5\3@:=65 688D 2?5 6G6? 324@? 2C6 2>@?8 E96 255:E:@?D A6@A=6 2C8F6 7@C :? 4@C?3C625 5C6DD:?8] tG6? H:E9@FE E9@D6 255:E:@?D[ E96 5:D9 42? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^6IA=@C6362F7@CED4]4@>^5C6DD:?8\@C\DEF77:?8\:ED\?@\4@?E6DE\:?\E96\D@FE9^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm2?49@C 2 >62=k^2m >256 FA @7 ?@E9:?8 >@C6 E92? 2 EFC<6J H:?8 2?5 2 =:EE=6 8C2GJ] (92E6G6C :D =67E 42? EFC? :?E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^4@@^E92?2D965\A@E2E@\A2EE:6D\C64:A6^QmDEF77:?8[ EFC<6J 2?5 A@E2E@ A2EE:6Dk^2m E96 ?6IE 52J]k^Am kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm(92E6G6C E96 5:D9 :D 42==65[